Islamic Economics Studies Bi-quarterly Journal

Compensating for the Depreciation of Fiat Money in Islamic Shariah, and the Paradox of its Fungibility

Document Type : Research Paper

Authors

1 PhD Student in Economics, Allameh Tabatabai University, Tehran, Iran

2 Assistant Professor, Faculty of Economics, Allameh Tabataba'i University, Tehran.Iran

3 applied economics , faculty of economics , allameh tabatabai-e university

Abstract

Inflation and its distributive effects have consistently been one of the most important economic and social issues in countries without stable economic policies. Periods of chronic and high inflation have given rise to legal and Shari'ah-related questions, one of which is whether or not it is necessary to compensate the depreciation of fiat money in long term debts, bank deposits, and the like. As the compensation creates an illusion of paying Riba, the jurisprudential judgments in the issue has gone into three categories: non-necessity (fungibility theory of fiat money), necessity (purchasing power theory of fiat money) and the middle solution (compensation for major losses). Criticizing all three points of view, this article presents a new explanation of the problem and a normative account of fungibility, contrary to the previous descriptive accounts which generally take fiat money system with depreciating money value for granted. Hence, the monetary system unable to meet the fungibility requirement set forth cannot be approved by Islamic jurisprudence. In the case of an antecedent inflation, compensation for major losses can only be prescribed as a "secondary law" (Aḥkām Al-Thānaviah) which is of a limited and temporary nature.

Keywords

Chapra, Muhammad Umer (1985). Towards A Just Monetary System. Leicester. UK: The Islamic Foundation.
Finch, David (1956). Purchasing Power Guarantees for Deferred Payments. In Staff Papers (International Monetary Fund). 5 )1(. 1-22.
Fisher, Irving (1928). The Money Illusion. Snowball Publishing.
Hasanuz Zaman, S. M. (1985). Indexation; An Islamic Evaluation. Journal of Research in Islamic Economics. 2 (2). 31-49.
Mises, Ludwig von (1990). Money, Method and the Market Process: Essays by Ludwig von Mises. Mises Institute.
Parkin, Michael (1987). Inflation. In Eatwell, John et al. (eds). The New Palgrave, A dictionary of economics. London: MacMillan.
Schumpeter, Joseph A. (1954). History of Economic Analysis. New York: University of Oxford Press.
Assefi, Mohammad Mahdi (1996). Shariáh Rulings on Money. Feqh-e Ahl-e Beyt. (7). 9-42. Qom: (In Persian)
Tajlil Tabrizi, Abutaleb (1996). Shariáh Rulings on Money. Feqh-e Ahl-e Beyt. (7). 9-42. Qom: (In Persian)
Taskhiri, Mohammad Ali (1996). The Change in Money Value and its Effect on Time Deposits. in The Proceedings of 7th Conference of Islamic Banking. Tehran: Iranian High Institute of Banking. (In Persian)
Tavassoli, Mohammad Esma’eil, (2015). Analyzing the Nature of Money and the Foundations of Monetary Policy in Islamic Economics. Qom: Research Institute of Hawzah and University. (In Persian)
al-Hurr al-Amili, Muhammad Ibn Hassan (1982). Wassaél al-Shiah. Tehran: al-Maktabah al-Islamiyyah.
Khouyi, Abolghassem (1999). Misbah al-Fiqaahah. The Compilation of A. Khouyi Lectures by Mohammad Ali Towhidi. Qom: al-Fiqaahah Publication.
Doroodiyan, Hossein (2015). The Nature of Money and the Effects of Money Creation in Conventional Economics, an Islamic Critical Evaluation. PhD Thesis. Tehran: Economics Faculty of Tehran University.
Group of Authors (1992). The Principles of Islamic Economics. Qom: Research Institute of Hawzah and University. (In Persian).
Group of Authors (1995). Money in Islamic Economics. Qom: Research Institute of Hawzah and University. (In Persian).
Sobhani, Jafar (1993). A Survey on the legal and Jurisprudential Problems of Money Depreciation. Rahnemoon Magazine. Tehran: High School of Shahid Motahhari. (6). (In Persian).
Saéedi, Seyed Mohsen (2006). Compensating for Money Depreciation. Feqh-e Ahl-e Beyt. (45). (In Persian).
Sadr, Seyed Mohammad Baqer (2014). Islam the Leader of Life, the Ideology of Islam. and our Mission. Qom: Dar as-Sadr. (In Persian).
Tabatabaí, Seyed Mohammad Sadeq and Sarmadi, Pegah (2015). Jurisprudential and Legal Possibility of Compensating Losses Aroused by Money Depreciation. Feqh va Hoghugh-e Eslami. (10). (In Persian).
Maráshi Shoushtari, Mohammad Hassan (1996). Shariáh Rulings on Money. Feqh-e Ahl-e Beyt. (7). 9-42. Qom: (In Persian).
Mesbahi, Gholamreza (1992). Some Problems of Riba-free Banking. Working Paper. Collaboration Office of Hawzah and University. IRI Central Bank Office of Human Resource Studies and Training. (In Persian).
Marefat, Mohammad Hadi (1996). Shariáh Rulings on Money. Feqh-e Ahl-e Beyt. (7). 9-42. Qom: (In Persian).
Moossayi, Meysam (1998). The Explanation of Concept and Subject of Riba from Jurisprudential Point of View. Tehran: Money and Banking Research Institute. Central Bank of Iran. (In Persian).
Moossavi Bojnordi, Seyed Mohammad (1996 a). Shariáh Rulings on Money. Feqh-e Ahl-e Beyt. (7). 9-42. Qom: (In Persian).
Moossavi Bojnordi, Seyed Mohammad (1996 b). The Role of Bank Notes in Islamic Legal System. in Money in the sight of Economics and Jurisprudence. Tehran: Research Institute for Islamic Culture and Thought.
Mirjalili, Seyed Hossein (2005). Compensating for Money Depreciation, Theory and Practice. Jostarha-ye Eghtessadi. (4). 207-229. (In Persian).
Valizaheh, Mohammad Javad and Haéri, Mohammad hassan (2010). The Relation of Fungible-Nonfungible goods distinction and Compensating for Money Depreciation. Motaleát-e Feqh va Hoghugh-e Eslami. (3). 133-161. (In Persian).
Hashemi Shahroodi, Seyed Mahmood (1995). Shariáh Rulings on Money Depreciation.  Feqh-e Ahl-e Beyt. (2). 52-98. (In Persian).
Youssefi, Ahmad Ali (1998). The Nature of Money. Qom: Research Institute for Islamic Culture and Thought. (In Persian).
Youssefi, Ahmad Ali (2002 a). Compensating for Money Depreciation in Debts and Finacial Relations.  Iqtissad-i Islami. (6). 45-66. (In Persian).
Youssefi, Ahmad Ali (2002 b). Riba and Inflation. a Comparative Study of Compensating for Money Depreciation and Riba. Tehran: Cultural Institute of Contemporary knowledge and Thought. (In Persian).
Youssefi, Ahmad Ali (2004). The Methods of Compensating for Money Depreciation in Bank Deposits. Iqtissad-e Islami. (13). 135-153. (In Persian).
Islamic Economics Studies Bi-quarterly Journal
Volume 13, Issue 1 - Serial Number 25
March 2020
Pages 85-116